"Mommy, that lady is smoking a cigarette because she's sad."
Annalise looked down with surprise at her daughter. The girl was prone to saying odd things, but this one was stranger than usual. Often, the statements were generalizations, but this time it was specific, about one person. Annalise looked up and across the street to the woman that her daughter was pointing at and noted that the woman was crying. Her eyeliner had run down her inner eyes, staining her otherwise lovely face.
"Mommy, why do tears make people so ugly? Sadness is beautiful." Annalise raised her eyebrows.
"What makes sadness beautiful? Most people consider sadness a bad thing."
"Sadness isn't bad. It's people that make it bad. Sadness is beautiful, like happiness. People just don't understand that because they're afraid." Annalise didn't know what to say.
"Why would anyone be afraid of sadness?"
"Because it's not happiness. People think that the only good feeling is happiness, but they're wrong. People don't know what good and bad are because they aren't real. They're just ideas, like love and hope and hate. Sadness is just as good as happiness, but people don't see it that way because people feel it when they don't get what they want. But if you learn to like sadness, then it's almost like happiness, and they're not very different. Then you can be happy almost all of the time." Again, Annalise had to search for words.
"If you're happy all the time, why don't you smile more often?"
"That's another thing about people. They think that a smile means you're happy but that's not true. Lots of people smile because they want people to think they're happy, because they're afraid to say that they're sad. They think saying it will make it more real, and they won't be able to change it. But that's wrong. They can change it, they just don't want to. That's why sometimes smiles are like lies. I don't like lies, mommy. Please don't ever lie to me." Annalise was taken aback.
"W--what? Why would I lie to you?"
"Because you're not like me. Everybody lies, even me sometimes, but I don't like it. Sometimes the truth gets all mixed up and I don't know what's true, but later when I can think thoughts again I can remember. You lie to me a lot, mommy--your eyes get watery and your forehead wrinkles a little. You lied about daddy and I know you lied about my life. Things don't always get better. You don't know that they will. You lied about your life, too. You lie all the time, about lots of things. But it's okay, because I still love you." ..What? How could a nine year old read this much of her? She was twenty-four years old, and her nine year old daughter was telling her things that her most intuitive suitors couldn't read even after years of knowing her. Not even her friends could spot her lies, but..
"I didn't lie about any of that, honey, that was all tr--"
"No! No it wasn't! None of it was true and you're lying again!"
"Ve--"
"No! I don't want to talk about it, mommy. It's okay if you're afraid, but please don't lie to me. You don't have to tell me, you can just not say anything. That's what I do instead of lying. It isn't the best but it's better."
"I'm sorry.. I just don't want to talk about those things with you. You aren't old enough to understand yet."
"Okay, mommy. You can tell me when you think I am." Annalise's daughter turned on her heel and looked up. "Hello, lady." Annalise looked up with her daughter and was shocked to see the woman with the cigarette standing there. She must have walked over during their conversation. The woman smiled slightly with the left corner of her mouth, and weakly raised her hand.
"Hi."
"Why are you so sad, lady?" Annalise wished she wouldn't be so forward with strangers, in--
"My husband was in a car accident. The dog and our cats were with him. They all died before the paramedics could save them."
"Are paramedics the people that come out of ambulances and save people?"
The lady dabbed at a daring tear. "Yes, they are."
"I'm sorry, lady." The girl said, and went right up to the woman's legs and put her arms around them, resting her cheek against the woman's thigh. The lady trembled for a moment, and then collapsed to the ground, knees pointed inwards, heels splayed. She was sobbing. Her shoulders heaved, and she hid her face in her hands. "Don't hide your face, lady! Your tears are beautiful." The woman stopped for a moment. She brought her face up to the girls, and looked into her eyes. The stare lasted a long time. Maybe for minutes. Annalise could only watch. There was an unusual tension in the air she hadn't felt from her daughter before.
After a few moments, the woman spoke. "Why are tears beautiful, little girl? What is so beautiful about this horrible feeling in my heart?"
"It's a feeling, lady. It means you love something in the world, and it means you can be happy again. It means that everything is going to be okay, lady. Tears are like little rain drops from clouds of sadness in our eyes. They come out and we can taste the sadness, and then it becomes happiness again. That's why it's beautiful, lady."
Nobody spoke for a long time. The woman stopped sobbing and Annalise stood, watching them. The girl stood with her arms limp at her sides, her eyes staring blankly into the woman's.
"How can you say that, little girl? Have you never felt like this? Nothing will ever be alright again! I've lost everything I ever cared about, and every reason to live. Tell me what's beautiful about that!" The woman laughed in scorn.
"You're angry because you're afraid of sadness, lady. But you can't do that. You can't be afraid of sadness. It hurts too much. You have to embrace it like a teddy bear and love it until it grows into happiness again. That's how I get better when I'm sad."
The woman shook her head. "How do you know any of this!? Look at my eyes! Look at them! Do you see how blue they are? It's because I'm miserable! They only get like that when I hate the world! I checked before I left, they're almost white! Can you tell me they aren't so bright, full of grief? Are you telling me THIS will turn into happiness?"
Annalise put a restraining hand on the woman's arm. "Please, stop! My daughter.. she's color blind. She can't see colors." The woman was silent.
"..so am I." The woman sat for a bit, then stood up and regained her posture. She pulled the left side of her coat up, and replaced her carrying bag on the other. She looked down at the girl for a while longer, and then right at Annalise. "She's going to grow up to be a beautiful, capable girl. I wish I could see her then." The woman rummaged in her bag and came out with a tattered old blue dog with a purple belly. Its left ear was a little torn, and its right ear was bent at an odd angle. It had a slight tear in the belly, and a small tuft of stuffing could be seen poking out. She knelt down and looked the girl in the eyes. "His name is Happiness. I want you to have him. I think he'll help you a lot more than it will help me now."
The girl nodded. "I think so too." The girl took the small stuffed animal in her hands, then hugged it to her chest. "Thank you, lady!" The woman smiled.
"What's your name, little girl, so I can have a name with the face of the owner of my only treasured possession left in this world?"
"My name is Sadness, lady. My name is Sadness."
And as the lady felt the pieces fall into place, one by one by one, she stood in helpless shock.
"Then.. I think it really does belong to you.." The woman whispered.
"What's your name?" Sadness asked.
"My name.. I don't have a name."
"You aren't lying. You don't have a name. But I'm going to give you a name."
The woman looked at her with a blank stare. "You're going to give me a name? Can you do that?"
"Yes. Your name is Happiness, lady. Just like your dog. Your name is Happiness."
And just as the girl said this last word, the woman's cell phone began to ring. She picked it up and answered, looking frantic. She didn't say anything, but kept nodding, until after a few minutes she mumbled "thank you" and hung up. She sat down again, and looked at the girl.
"Who was that?" Sadness asked.
"The.. the hospital called. They said--they said my husband is going to be okay."
Sadness nodded. "I know." She took Annalise's hand and started walking away from the woman, now named Happiness. Before she got too far, the lady shouted two words. The girl, without smiling, without seemingly even hearing them, turned her head, still walking, and said, quietly, "I know." She turned her head back around, and continued walking down the sidewalk, towards the setting sun. Her eyes were maybe a little more blue than they were before. Maybe they even contained a little sparkle. Sadness can do that.
But just a little.
------------------
Meh. I don't even know. Not where I expected the story to go. I'm kind of disappointed with it. Maybe I'll rewrite it sometime. Maybe I'll suddenly be content with it.
I don't know.
I guess we'll see.